How to read this book
This book is about ten good qualities that the Buddha built up over many, many lives before he became the Buddha. They are called the ten pāramī (perfections). Each chapter takes one of them, explains it in plain words, and tells a true story from the Buddha’s past lives to show it in action.
Pali words. The Buddha’s teaching was written down in a language called Pali. You will meet Pali words all through this book. Every time one appears, its English meaning sits right next to it in brackets, like this: dāna (giving), citta (mind). You never have to remember a Pali word to understand the page. But if you do remember a few, you will be able to read the ancient texts one day.
Saying the words. A line over a letter makes it long: ā sounds like the “a” in “father”, ī like the “ee” in “see”, ū like the “oo” in “moon”. A dot under a letter (ṭ, ḍ, ṇ) means you curl your tongue back a little. ñ sounds like the “ny” in “canyon”. ṃ sounds like “ng”. So paññā is said “pan-nyaa” and mettā is said “met-taa”.
Hard words. Some English words in this book are hard. The first time a hard word is met in a chapter it has a small number after it, like this: aeons⁵. Its meaning is given at the end of the chapter, under “Hard words in this chapter”, and all the hard words are listed together at the back, after the word list. In the web edition, tapping or clicking on the word shows its meaning.
Quizzes. After every two chapters there is a short quiz.
Where the stories come from. The stories are not made up. They come from the Jātaka (birth stories) and the Cariyāpiṭaka (Basket of Conduct), two books of the Tipiṭaka (the Three Baskets, the oldest collection of the Buddha’s teaching), and from the old commentaries that explain them. The Buddha told these stories himself. In each one he is the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be), the person who is working, life after life, to become a Buddha. The way they are told here follows the book The Perfections Leading to Enlightenment by Sujin Boriharnwanaket, translated by Nina van Gorkom, which you can read for free on abhidhamma.org when you are older.
Introduction: what is a perfection?
Imagine a wide, fast river. On this side live all the troubles of the mind: wanting, anger, ignorance1not knowing; not understanding what is really there, fear. On the far side there is peace, with none of those troubles. The ancient texts call the far side nibbāna (the end of all troubles). A pāramī (perfection2a good quality made as full and strong as it can be) is a good quality that carries a person across. That is what the word means: something that goes across to the far shore.
There are ten of them. Here they are, with their Pali names:
| Pali | English | What it is in one line |
|---|---|---|
| dāna | giving | sharing what one has |
| sīla | good conduct | not harming by deed3something done; an act, good or bad or word |
| nekkhamma | letting go | being happy with enough |
| paññā | wisdom | seeing things as they really are |
| viriya | energy4effort; the strength that keeps on going | not being lazy about doing good |
| khanti | patience | putting up with hard things calmly |
| sacca | truthfulness5always telling the truth and keeping to it | being honest in word and deed |
| adhiṭṭhāna | determination6making up one’s mind firmly and keeping to it | holding firmly to a good aim |
| mettā | loving-kindness7wishing others well; friendliness to everyone | wanting others to be well |
| upekkhā | even-mindedness8having a mind that stays level and calm whatever happens | staying steady when things go up or down |
What a person really is. The Abhidhamma (the higher teaching) is the part of the Tipiṭaka (the Three Baskets) that explains what the mind really is. It says that what people call a person is really a stream of moments. In each moment there is a citta (consciousness9a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing), a moment of knowing something, and with it some cetasika (mental factors10something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering): feeling, liking, disliking, kindness, laziness and so on. Each citta (consciousness) arises11to come up; to begin; to happen because of conditions12something that has to be there before another thing can happen, falls away13to end; to stop; to be gone at once, and another takes its place. There is no little person inside who owns them. The ancient texts call this anattā (non-self14not a self; not a person; not anyone’s). So when this book says that someone gives, or someone is patient, that is only the ordinary way of talking. What is really there is a citta (consciousness) with good cetasika (mental15to do with the mind factors).
Good moments and bad moments. A citta (consciousness) can be kusala (good) or akusala (bad). Every perfection is kusala (good). But not every good deed is a perfection. What makes the difference is the aim behind it. A gift given in the hope of praise, or of being rich in the next life, is still kusala (good). But it is not a perfection. It is a perfection when the danger of wanting, anger and ignorance has been seen, and the aim is to be free of them. The opposite of all ten perfections is lobha (attachment16wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go, wanting). A perfection is good done without wanting anything back.
Three roots of trouble. Akusala (bad) states grow from three roots: lobha (attachment), dosa (anger) and moha (ignorance). These three, and the other bad cetasika (mental factors) that grow from them, are called kilesa (defilements17something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest), the things that dirty the mind. All ten perfections work against the kilesa (defilements), until one day they are gone.
How each one begins. Each perfection begins when the harm in its opposite is seen. When the harm of stinginess18not wanting to give or share; meanness is seen, giving arises. When the harm of hurting others is seen, good conduct arises. When the harm of laziness is seen, effort arises. When the harm of impatience is seen, patience arises. When the harm of wanting to get back at people is seen, kindness arises. It is the same for all ten.
Medicine for the mind. The road to the far shore is very long. The ancient texts call it the ariya aṭṭhaṅgika magga (the noble eightfold path). A sick and weak person cannot walk a long road, even if the way is known. The kilesa (defilements) are the sickness. The ten perfections are the medicine that makes the citta (consciousness) strong enough to walk the whole way.
Wishing is not deciding. Some people do a good deed and then pray for a reward. That is a wish, not adhiṭṭhāna (determination). Determination is the firm aim of reaching the far shore and not letting that aim go.
Hard words in this chapter
- ignorance: not knowing; not understanding what is really there
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- energy: effort; the strength that keeps on going
- truthfulness: always telling the truth and keeping to it
- determination: making up one's mind firmly and keeping to it
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
- even-mindedness: having a mind that stays level and calm whatever happens
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- mental factor: something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- condition: something that has to be there before another thing can happen
- fall away: to end; to stop; to be gone
- non-self: not a self; not a person; not anyone's
- mental: to do with the mind
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
- stinginess: not wanting to give or share; meanness
Chapter 1. Dāna (giving)
Dāna (giving) comes first in the list of ten, and there is a reason. A person who cannot let go of a small thing, a sweet or a pencil, will find it much harder to let go of the biggest thing of all: the idea that nāma (mind) and rūpa (matter1the kind of reality that does not know or feel anything, such as hardness, colour or sound) are “me” and “mine”. Giving is practice in letting go.
| Dāna (giving) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | letting go of something |
| What it does | pushes away greed for things that could be given |
| How it shows itself | not holding on tightly |
| What it needs | something that can be given away |
Giving and understanding. Dāna (giving) is giving things away for the good and the happiness of others. At the moment of giving there is no selfishness. The giving can be with paññā (wisdom) or without it. Wisdom at the moment of giving remembers that nothing lasts: not the gift, not the one who gives, not the one who receives.
Three kinds of gift. The ancient texts name three kinds of dāna (giving).
- Āmisa dāna (giving things): food, clothes, money, time, a seat on the bus.
- Abhaya dāna (giving freedom from fear). When someone decides never to kill any living being2any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being, every creature in the world receives a gift: safety. The same is true of not stealing, not lying, not hurting. The Buddha said that a person who keeps these rules “gives to immeasurable3too big to measure beings freedom from fear”. Forgiving is also a gift of this kind: the person who is forgiven is safe from that anger.
- Dhamma dāna (giving the teaching). This is the highest gift. A meal fills a hungry person for a day. Helping someone understand what is really good and really harmful helps them in this life and in the lives to come.
When is giving a perfection? Only when nothing is wanted back. Not praise. Not a present in return. Not even a happy rebirth4being born again in a new life after this one ends in a deva (heavenly being) world. Giving done in order to look good is still kusala (good), but it is not a perfection5a good quality made as full and strong as it can be. Only the citta (consciousness6a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing) at the moment of giving shows which it is.
How the Bodhisatta gave. The ancient commentary7an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear tells how the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) gave in his past lives:
- When he saw that someone needed something, he gave it before they asked.
- He gave what people wanted, not what they did not want.
- If there was not enough for everyone, he shared out evenly what there was.
- He never gave things that harm people: weapons, poison, strong drink. He did not give a sick person food that would make them worse, even if they begged for it.
- He gave with a smile and kind words, never with a frown.
- If he gave food, he added clothes. If he gave clothes, he added food.
- If he noticed greed growing for some beautiful thing of his, he found someone to give the thing to, and gave it away.
The four knots. Sometimes there is something to give and someone who needs it, and still the citta (consciousness) does not want to give. The commentary names four knots that tie giving up, and the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) had a thought ready for each one.
- Not feeling like it. Giving does not come easily now because it was not practised in the past. So he gave anyway, so that in the future the mind would be glad to give.
- The poor gift. His things were poor now because he had not given in the past. So he gave what he had.
- The beautiful gift. He had set his heart on the highest goal of all. For that goal it was right to give the loveliest things.
- Loss. All things get lost and wear out, whether they are given or not. So he gave.
That last thought is worth keeping. Fires, floods, thieves and kings take people’s things all the time. Whether a thing is kept or lost depends on kamma (deeds8something done; an act, good or bad and their results9what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed), not on whether it was given.
Three moments. Cetanā (intention10what the mind means to do; the mind’s choosing) in giving has three moments: before, when the decision to give is made; during, when the gift is handed over; after, when the giving is remembered. The citta (consciousness) can be kusala (good) at all three moments, or it can slip. Someone gives gladly, and afterwards thinks with pride what a generous11giving freely and gladly person they are. That afterthought is lobha (attachment12wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go), not giving. So the mind has to be watched.
A gift that cannot be held. Can a sound be given? The commentary says it can. A drum can be given to a temple, so that the drum can be beaten. The teaching can be chanted aloud. Gladness at someone else’s good deed can be said out loud. That last one has a name: anumodana (rejoicing13to be glad in another’s good deed). It costs nothing, and it is a gift.
Hard words in this chapter
- matter: the kind of reality that does not know or feel anything, such as hardness, colour or sound
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- immeasurable: too big to measure
- rebirth: being born again in a new life after this one ends
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- result: what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed
- intention: what the mind means to do; the mind's choosing
- generosity: giving freely and gladly
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- rejoice: to be glad
Chapter 2. Sīla (good conduct)
Sīla (good conduct) means not harming anyone by what is done or said. The ancient texts call it tapa (burning away), because good conduct burns away the dirt of akusala (bad states).
| Sīla (good conduct) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | keeping deeds1something done; an act, good or bad and words in order |
| What it does | drives out bad behaviour |
| How it shows itself | a clean way of living |
| What it needs | hiri (shame at doing wrong) and ottappa (fear of the results2what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed of doing wrong) |
The five rules. The most basic sīla (good conduct) is the pañca sīla (five precepts3a rule of good conduct):
- not to kill any living being4any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- not to take what is not given
- not to do wrong in sexual matters
- not to lie
- not to drink or take anything that clouds the mind
When one of these rules is broken, the citta (consciousness5a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing) behind it is always akusala (bad). At that moment there is no mettā (loving-kindness6wishing others well; friendliness to everyone) for the one being harmed. A sotāpanna (stream-enterer, a person who has reached the first stage of enlightenment7the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away) keeps all five rules perfectly and can never break them again. Nobody else can promise that. But the rules can still be kept, moment by moment, long before that stage is reached.
Two kinds of shame. Two cetasika (mental factors8something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering) are the nearest cause of good conduct. Hiri (shame) comes from inside: its nearest cause is respect for oneself. Ottappa (fear of blame) comes from outside: its nearest cause is respect for someone else. The two always arise9to come up; to begin; to happen together, and both keep the rules. If a person breaks a rule by forgetting, shame or fear of blame makes him quickly put it right.
The story of Akitti. Long ago the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was an ascetic10a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living named Akitti. He lived alone in a forest beside a great Kāra tree. When the tree had fruit, he ate the fruit. When it had none, he ate its leaves, boiled in water, and he gathered only enough for one meal a day.
Sakka, the king of the devas (heavenly beings), saw this pure and simple life and wondered what Akitti wanted. Perhaps he wanted to become Sakka himself? So Sakka came down disguised as a brahmin11a man of the priestly class in ancient India (a priest) and stood before the hut as if asking for food.
Akitti saw that the brahmin needed food. He gave him all the leaves. The next day the brahmin came again, and Akitti gave him all the leaves again. The third day, the same. Sakka saw that this was no bargain for heaven. It was dāna (giving) with sīla (good conduct), nekkhamma (letting go), khanti (patience), viriya (energy12effort; the strength that keeps on going), adhiṭṭhāna (determination13making up one’s mind firmly and keeping to it) and sacca (truthfulness14always telling the truth and keeping to it) all at once, with no wish for anything back. In each of his lives the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) developed all ten perfections15a good quality made as full and strong as it can be together.
Sakka showed himself and asked why Akitti lived there alone. Akitti answered: “Sakka, King of the devas, rebirth16being born again in a new life after this one ends is dukkha, the breaking up of the body is dukkha, and dying with delusion17being fooled; not seeing things as they are is dukkha. Therefore I dwell here all alone.” Dukkha (suffering18pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness) is the way everything that arises never quite satisfies.
Sakka was pleased and offered him any wish he liked. Akitti asked, one wish at a time:
- To be free from all attachment19wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go, even the harmless kind that people feel for their children and their things.
- That there be no akusala kamma (bad deed) that could make him lose land, goods, cattle or relatives.
- Not to see, hear or sit with fools, because fools advise what is wrong and answer good advice with anger.
- That people see the wise and listen to them, because the wise advise what is right.
- That holy beggars might come to his hut each morning, that the food he offered them never run out, and that he never regret his giving.
- That Sakka never visit him again.
That last wish surprised Sakka. Most people long to see a deva (heavenly being). Akitti explained that devas (heavenly beings) are glorious and delightful to look at, and seeing them might make him break his vow. Sakka agreed, and left. Akitti lived in that place all his life and was reborn in the brahma (highest heavenly) world. The Buddha said that Sakka in that story was Anuruddha, one of his great disciples20a pupil; someone who follows a teacher, and Akitti was himself.
Jotipāla and the bad friends. Akitti stayed away from fools, and the next story shows why. In another life the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was a young brahmin (priest) called Jotipāla. His family had no faith in the Buddha of that age, the Buddha Kassapa, and Jotipāla copied his parents and looked down on the Buddha too. The commentary21an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear says that all the perfections Jotipāla had gathered over so many lives were like a bright blazing fire. In that life the fire met water: the fire went out, and only black charcoal was left. Bad company can do that even to a Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be). The commentary compares the company of fools to drinking bitter water, and the company of the wise to drinking sweet water.
Two sides of good conduct. Vāritta sīla (conduct as avoiding) is not doing wrong: the five rules. Cāritta sīla (conduct as doing) is doing what is right. The commentary lists what the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) did. He greeted good people with respect. He looked after them when they were ill. He put up with insults from unkind people. He remembered every kindness done to him. When he did wrong, he admitted it. He guided the blind and found a cart for those who could not walk. He hid his own good qualities and admitted his faults. And when he heard about the great deeds of Bodhisattas (Buddhas-to-be) of the past, he was not frightened off. They were only human beings, who trained step by step, and the same training would bring him to the same goal.
Good conduct right now. A dear friend does something wrong, and without thinking a person scolds the friend in front of everyone. When sati (mindfulness22noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting, remembering what is good) arises instead, the scolding waits, and the friend is spoken to later, kindly and alone. The kilesa (defilements23something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest) have to be worn away like that, again and again.
Hard words in this chapter
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- result: what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed
- precept: a rule of good conduct
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- mental factor: something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- ascetic: a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living
- brahmin: a man of the priestly class in ancient India
- energy: effort; the strength that keeps on going
- determination: making up one's mind firmly and keeping to it
- truthfulness: always telling the truth and keeping to it
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- rebirth: being born again in a new life after this one ends
- delusion: being fooled; not seeing things as they are
- suffering: pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- disciple: a pupil; someone who follows a teacher
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- mindfulness: noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
Quiz 1 (chapters 1 and 2)
Click an answer. Each question tells you at once whether it is right. For the written ones, show the answer and mark yourself.
Chapter 3. Nekkhamma (letting go)
Nekkhamma (letting go) is turning away from the chase after pleasant sights, sounds, smells, tastes and touches. Most people think it means becoming a monk1a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life. The ancient texts say it can begin at home, at the moment someone looks at what they have and finds it is enough.
| Nekkhamma (letting go) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | moving away from sense pleasures |
| What it does | shows that they never quite satisfy |
| How it shows itself | drawing back from them |
| What it needs | saṃvega (a sense of urgency2the feeling that something must be done now, without delay, a jolt that says life is short) |
Three kinds of thinking. The ancient texts name three wrong ways of thinking: kāma vitakka (thinking about sense pleasures), vyāpāda vitakka (thinking with hate) and vihiṃsā vitakka (thinking about hurting). The opposite of the first is nekkhamma vitakka (thinking of letting go). When the mind wants more pleasant things than it already has, that is kāma vitakka (thinking about sense pleasures). When the mind finds that what it has is enough, that is nekkhamma vitakka (thinking of letting go). A person who stops buying more clothes just to look nice, and gives the spare ones to someone who can use them, has nekkhamma (letting go) in daily life.
Monk or not. A monk who still clings3holding on tightly; not wanting to let go to pleasant things just as a layperson4an ordinary person who follows the teaching while living at home does is, in that way, no different from a layperson. And a layperson who clings less is practising nekkhamma (letting go) without a robe. Clinging to the five sense objects5the thing that a moment of mind knows: a colour, a sound, a thought is not fully gone until a person becomes an anāgāmī (non-returner, the third stage of enlightenment6the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away). Until then, the work is to make the clinging smaller, bit by bit.
The story of Sona and Nanda. The Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was once born as Sona, the son of a very rich brahmin7a man of the priestly class in ancient India (priest). His little brother was Nanda, who in a later life became the Venerable Ānanda, the Buddha’s attendant.
Their parents wanted them to marry. Sona would not. He wanted to look after his parents all their lives and then become an ascetic8a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living (a person who gives up home and comfort to train the mind). Nanda said that he would do the same. Then the parents decided to go with them. All four left home and built a hut in the forest, and the two brothers cared for their parents.
Nanda gathered fruit the day before and served it early in the morning. But fruit kept from the day before was sometimes spoilt or unripe. Sona went further into the forest for sweet ripe fruit, but by the time he came back the parents had already eaten Nanda’s fruit. Sona was worried: the parents were old, and bad fruit would shorten their lives. He told Nanda to wait each day until he came back, so that both could serve the parents together. Nanda did not listen. He wanted the merit9goodness earned by a good deed, which brings a good result later of feeding the parents to be his own. So Sona sent him away.
Nanda went off alone and developed deep calm of mind and the higher powers. Then he wanted to ask his brother’s forgiveness, in the grandest way he could. He thought of bringing Sakka, the king of the devas (heavenly beings10any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being), but decided that was not fitting. Instead he brought the mightiest king on earth, King Manoja. So the king came to the hut, and Nanda was forgiven. From then on Nanda looked after their mother and Sona looked after their father. Then Sona taught the king about caring for one’s parents:
Joy, careless ease, laughter and sport, are the sure heritage
Of him that studiously11carefully, like a hard-working student shall tend a mother in old age.
Where is the nekkhamma (letting go) in this story? Sona gave up a fortune and a wedding, paid no attention to sense pleasures, and used every spare moment to develop jhāna (deep calm of mind).
Letting go in small things. Three everyday examples.
- Pictures. Something beautiful is seen and enjoyed. If sati (mindfulness12noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting) arises13to come up; to begin; to happen, it is known that this is only a dhamma (a reality14something that is really there, not only a name or an idea) appearing. When the beautiful thing is not there, it is not searched for.
- Food. A person is full, but the food is delicious, so one more mouthful goes in. That is the citta (consciousness15a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing) clinging to taste. Eating just enough to feed the body is nekkhamma (letting go).
- Baths. Some people love a warm bath, or a cold one, even when the body does not need it. The bath is fine. The clinging to the temperature is the thing to notice.
Letting go is happiness. An ancient text, the Cūḷaniddesa (a book of the Tipiṭaka), says that nekkhamma (letting go) is a refuge, a protection and a place of no danger, and that it comes with happiness. Only paññā (wisdom) sees this, by comparing the two ways of living and finding out which one is really better.
The sick man and the string. A sick man cannot turn over by himself. The nurse ties a string to the bed so he can pull himself round. Pulling the string gives the body a little comfort, but it gives the mind no ease at all. Beings burning with the kilesa (defilements16something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest) are like that. They cannot pull themselves out by the comfort of a quiet life alone. They need the perfections17a good quality made as full and strong as it can be.
The story of Susīma. The Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) thought that in his life as Susīma. Susīma was the son of the king’s priest, and he grew up with the prince. When the prince became king, he made Susīma his adviser. One day the king’s mother saw Susīma riding behind the king on an elephant, fell in love with him, and was so unhappy that she stopped eating. The king solved it by making Susīma the king, with his mother as queen, while he himself became the second in command.
Susīma now had a queen, a palace and a whole kingdom. And from that day he was weary of it all. The queen tried every trick to make him enjoy his reign18the time during which a king rules. Instead Susīma taught the court about both the delight and the misery of sense pleasures, and then he handed the kingdom back. He went to the forest, became an ascetic, and developed jhāna (deep calm of mind). The Buddha said that the queen was Rāhula’s mother, the king was Ānanda, and Susīma was himself.
Nobody can order it. Nobody can tell another person to stop clinging. Nobody can even order themselves to stop. What can happen is this: paññā (wisdom) comes to see that the clinging is not worth keeping. Then it begins, slowly, to let go.
Hard words in this chapter
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- urgency: the feeling that something must be done now, without delay
- clinging: holding on tightly; not wanting to let go
- lay: an ordinary person who follows the teaching while living at home
- object: the thing that a moment of mind knows: a colour, a sound, a thought
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- brahmin: a man of the priestly class in ancient India
- ascetic: a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living
- merit: goodness earned by a good deed, which brings a good result later
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- studiously: carefully, like a hard-working student
- mindfulness: noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- reality: something that is really there, not only a name or an idea
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- reign: the time during which a king rules
Chapter 4. Paññā (wisdom)
Paññā (wisdom) is the cetasika (mental factor1something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering) that understands things as they really are. Without it, none of the other perfections2a good quality made as full and strong as it can be can do their full work. A person may be generous3giving freely and gladly, well behaved and patient, but the kilesa (defilements4something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest) can never be removed unless paññā (wisdom) grows sharp enough to see the truth. The commentary5an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear gives three pictures for it.
| Paññā (wisdom) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | seeing straight into the true nature of things, like an arrow shot by a skilled archer |
| What it does | lights things up, like a lamp |
| How it shows itself | no confusion, like a good guide in a forest |
| What it needs | samādhi (a steady mind) or the four noble truths |
The lamp. A man carries an oil lamp into a dark house. The darkness goes, and things can be seen. In the same way, when paññā (wisdom) arises6to come up; to begin; to happen, the darkness of avijjā (ignorance7not knowing; not understanding what is really there) goes and the four noble truths can be seen. The ancient texts say that paññā (wisdom) means “it penetrates”: it goes right through to the truth that “this is dukkha” (suffering8pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness).
Prince Yudañjaya and the dewdrops. The Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was once Yudañjaya, the king’s eldest son. Every day he gave mahā-dāna (a great offering of gifts). One morning, early, he went to the royal park. Dewdrops hung like strings of pearls on the tree tops, on the tips of the grass and on spiders’ webs. Then the sun rose, and one by one the dewdrops vanished.
The prince thought: these dewdrops came and went. All things that arise because of conditions9something that has to be there before another thing can happen, including the lives of every living being10any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being, are like dewdrops on the grass. A great sense of saṃvega (urgency11the feeling that something must be done now, without delay) came over him. He asked his parents’ leave and went to the forest to live as an ascetic12a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living.
Many people see dewdrops. Very few are stirred by them to compare their own lives with a dewdrop. When that kind of understanding arises, it should not be let slip. It should be thought about, so that it arises again and again. The commentary shows that in this one life the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) fulfilled all ten perfections: giving by his great offerings, letting go by leaving home, wisdom by his thought about the dewdrops, and the rest.
Old Piṅgiya. The brahmin13a man of the priestly class in ancient India (priest) Piṅgiya was a hundred and twenty years old. He was weak, and his eyes and ears were failing. He came to the Buddha and asked for only one thing: that the Buddha explain the teaching that makes an end of birth and old age. The Buddha told him that clinging14holding on tightly; not wanting to let go to rūpa (matter15the kind of reality that does not know or feel anything, such as hardness, colour or sound, the body and the things sensed through it) should be given up. When the talk was over, Piṅgiya had reached enlightenment16the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away. A person who has paññā (wisdom) would not ask for anything else, however old and tired.
Life lasts one moment. The ancient texts say there are three kinds of death. Sammuti maraṇa (conventional17the ordinary everyday way of talking, as when a pile of parts is called a chariot death) is what everyone calls death, at the end of a life. Samuccheda maraṇa (final death) is the passing away of an arahant (a fully enlightened person), who is never born again. And khaṇika maraṇa (momentary18lasting only a moment death) is death at every moment. Life is a series of citta (moments of consciousness19a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing), one after another. At this moment there is seeing. Seeing arises, sees, and dies, all in a flash. Then there is hearing, and it dies too. People say a life is long, but really life lasts for one moment of citta (consciousness) at a time. A person who understands this sees how pointless it is to cling to things that are gone before they can be held.
What is harder than swallowing a sword? A king in Magadha (a kingdom in India) had three wise councillors: Senaka, Āyura and Pukkusa. Senaka was the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be). A young man of the court fell in love with the queen and lay down sick with longing. The king took pity on him and said that the queen might go to him for seven days. But the two of them fell in love and ran away to another country.
The king was so full of grief20deep sadness, as when someone dies that he fell ill, and no doctor could cure him. Senaka knew that the sickness was in the king’s mind, and he thought of a cure. He arranged a show in which a man swallowed a sharp sword thirty-three inches long. The king asked the wise Āyura whether anything in the world was harder than that. Āyura answered that it is harder to say, “I shall give this away”. The king thought: I said I would give the queen, so I have done a hard thing. His grief grew a little lighter.
Then he asked Pukkusa whether anything was harder than saying one will give. Pukkusa answered that to make a promise and really let go of the thing is harder still. The king thought: I promised, and I did give her. His grief grew lighter still.
Then he asked Senaka whether anything was harder than giving. Senaka answered that the hardest thing of all is to give a gift and never regret it afterwards. The king thought: I gave the queen, and then I was sorry about it, and that was not right. What is the use of grieving over her? With that thought all his sorrow slid away like a drop of water off a lotus21a water flower that grows up from the mud and opens clean above the water leaf, and he was well. The Buddha told this story to a monk22a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life who wanted to leave the Order because his former wife was tempting him. That monk had been the king. Āyura was Mahā-Moggallāna, Pukkusa was Sāriputta, and Senaka was the Buddha.
Regret. Regret after giving shows that there is still clinging to the thing given. But in truth there is nobody who owns it, and nobody who can keep it, because every rūpa (matter) and every nāma (mind) falls away23to end; to stop; to be gone the moment it has arisen. Wisdom that sees this can give without being sorry.
The angry moment. When someone is angry with another person, paññā (wisdom) can remember that the other person, in truth, is only citta (consciousness), cetasika (mental24to do with the mind factors) and rūpa (matter), arising and falling away. That person will not be in this world for long. Nobody knows whether this meeting is the last one. A mind that remembers this becomes gentle, and mettā (loving-kindness25wishing others well; friendliness to everyone) can arise in place of the anger.
Hard words in this chapter
- mental factor: something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- generosity: giving freely and gladly
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- ignorance: not knowing; not understanding what is really there
- suffering: pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness
- condition: something that has to be there before another thing can happen
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- urgency: the feeling that something must be done now, without delay
- ascetic: a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living
- brahmin: a man of the priestly class in ancient India
- clinging: holding on tightly; not wanting to let go
- matter: the kind of reality that does not know or feel anything, such as hardness, colour or sound
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- conventional: the ordinary everyday way of talking, as when a pile of parts is called a chariot
- momentary: lasting only a moment
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- grief: deep sadness, as when someone dies
- lotus: a water flower that grows up from the mud and opens clean above the water
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- fall away: to end; to stop; to be gone
- mental: to do with the mind
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
Quiz 2 (chapters 3 and 4)
Click an answer. Each question tells you at once whether it is right. For the written ones, show the answer and mark yourself.
Chapter 5. Viriya (energy)
Viriya (energy1effort; the strength that keeps on going) is effort. The ancient texts say it is the state of a courageous person. When viriya (energy) arises2to come up; to begin; to happen, a person is not lazy or slack.
| Viriya (energy) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | striving |
| What it does | strengthens and supports |
| How it shows itself | not getting tired of the task |
| What it needs | an occasion for making an effort, or saṃvega (a sense of urgency3the feeling that something must be done now, without delay) |
Energy for good and energy for bad. Here is something most people never think about. The cetasika (mental factor4something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering) viriya (energy) arises with almost every citta (consciousness5a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing), good or bad. When there is attachment6wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go to something, energy is there, working for the attachment. Even a coward has viriya (energy), energy for cowardice. Even a lazy person has viriya (energy), energy that goes into being lazy again and again. So energy by itself is not a perfection7a good quality made as full and strong as it can be. The perfection of energy is effort for kusala (good). A question to ask: the viriya (energy) that arises now, is it kusala (good) or akusala (bad)? Most of the time it is likely to be working for lobha (attachment).
Nobody makes the effort. When sati (mindfulness8noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting) is aware of what appears at this moment, there is no “me” who makes an effort to be aware. The effort is the work of sammā-vāyāma (right effort), a cetasika (mental9to do with the mind factor). Viriya (energy) is not weary of the task, even when understanding grows very slowly.
Even giving needs energy. A person may have the good intention10what the mind means to do; the mind’s choosing to give something away, and still not give it, because he is lazy. The thing is there, and the intention is there, but the viriya (energy) to carry it out is missing. The same is true of all the other perfections. Sometimes a person thinks that doing good is troublesome, or that he is too tired. At such moments akusala (bad states) have won. Life lasts one moment of citta (consciousness), so good should be done at once, not later.
Three pictures of energy. The Atthasālinī (The Expositor, an ancient commentary11an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear) gives pictures of what viriya (energy) does.
- The old house. An old house that is falling down is held up by new pillars. When viriya (energy) supports a person, good states do not fall away12to end; to stop; to be gone in him. Someone who is bored, lazy or sleepy is like a house that is falling down.
- The small army. A small army goes into battle and is pushed back. The king sends strong reinforcements, and the army wins. In the same way viriya (energy) does not let the good states retreat; it lifts them up.
- The ox in the marsh. A strong ox is set to pull a load out of a marsh. It presses the ground with its knees and does not let the load drop. In the same way viriya (energy) takes up the work of doing good and does not drop it.
The city of bandits and the city of peace. The Venerable Sāriputta gave this picture. There were two cities, a city of bandits and a city of peace. A general thought: so long as the city of bandits exists, the city of peace is not safe. So he put on his armour, went into the city of bandits, broke down its gate and its walls, filled in its moat and set fire to it. Then he went into the city of peace and sat down to a fine meal with his family. The city of bandits is sakkāya-diṭṭhi (personality belief, the wrong view13a wrong idea about what is real, such as the idea that there is a lasting self that there is a self). The city of peace is nibbāna (the end of all troubles). The general is the person who develops the mind. Wrong view has to be destroyed first, and that takes courage.
The hero. The Buddha was called vīra (a hero). The ancient texts say why: “He had perseverance and was therefore called a hero. He was valiant and was therefore called a hero. He caused others to persevere and was therefore called a hero.” Under the Bodhi tree, before he became the Buddha, he said that he would not move from his seat even if his skin, veins and bones dried up. That is viriya (energy) at its highest.
Four right efforts. The Buddha taught four sammā-ppadhāna (right efforts):
- the effort to avoid akusala (bad states) that have not yet arisen
- the effort to overcome akusala (bad states) that have arisen
- the effort to develop kusala (good states) that have not yet arisen
- the effort to keep the kusala (good states) that have arisen and bring them to completion
Looking at oneself. The teachers of old said that a monk14a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life should examine himself three times a day: in the morning, in the daytime and in the evening. If he cannot do it three times, then twice. If he cannot do it twice, then once. But not to examine oneself at all is wrong. Nobody else can see a person’s akusala (bad states) as closely as that person can. Someone who examines himself honestly is “easy to speak to”. Someone who sees only other people’s faults is “difficult to speak to”. All of this depends on viriya (energy).
Energy is in the mind. The ancient texts say that viriya (energy) is always mental, never bodily. A monk who walks up and down to keep himself awake seems to be using bodily energy. In truth the walking happens because of viriya (energy), which is a cetasika (mental factor).
The man of eighty. The book tells of a man of about eighty who had listened to the teaching for many years. When he heard a radio talk about vipassanā (insight15seeing into something; here, seeing clearly for oneself that there is only mind and matter), he wrote down the address of the Dhamma Study and Support Foundation and set out to go there to make a donation. He left his house at nine in the morning and arrived at two in the afternoon. He had no time for lunch. That is the viriya (energy) of an old man who went against his own comfort in order to do good.
Trying too hard. Some people want to see results16what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed quickly, so they strive with all their might. They get tired and have to stop. The result cannot be made to come sooner. Satipaṭṭhāna (mindfulness of realities17something that is really there, not only a name or an idea) is awareness18noticing what is really there right now; another word for mindfulness of what naturally appears in daily life, and it cannot be hurried.
King Saṃvara. The Saṃvara Jātaka (birth story number 462) was told about a monk who had stopped trying. He had studied for five years, then gone to the forest and worked hard at his meditation19developing the mind; people use this word in many different ways for three months, and reached nothing. He decided that he could understand only the words, and went back to the Buddha. The Buddha told him that the highest fruit of the teaching cannot be reached by someone who is lazy, and that in the past he had been full of energy: although he had been the youngest of the hundred sons of the King of Vārāṇasī, he had become king.
King Saṃvara, the youngest of a hundred princes, was chosen as king by his brothers and the people because of his good qualities. His eldest brother, Prince Uposatha, asked him how this had come about. Saṃvara answered that he never grudged20to give unwillingly honour to the great sages21a wise person, but fell at their feet with a humble mind. Wise men taught him, and he liked to listen and had no envy22being unhappy because someone else has something good. He paid his soldiers what was due to them, and wise counsellors23a person who gives advice to a king helped him, so that the city had plenty and merchants from other lands prospered24to do well; to grow rich. When the people heard this, they saw that he was worthy to be king.
At the end the Buddha said: “Monk, long ago you followed the instruction, but why do you not now strive?” The monk became a sotāpanna (stream-enterer). He had been King Saṃvara. Sāriputta had been Prince Uposatha. The courtier25a person who serves at a king’s court who advised the king had been the Buddha himself.
Three occasions. The Buddha said that energy is to be put forth on three occasions: to prevent bad states that have not arisen, to bring about good states that have not arisen, and to endure26to bear something hard without giving up bodily feelings that are painful and sharp. A person who makes an effort on these three occasions is called “strenuous27needing great effort, wise and mindful so that he makes an end of dukkha”.
Hard words in this chapter
- energy: effort; the strength that keeps on going
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- urgency: the feeling that something must be done now, without delay
- mental factor: something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- mindfulness: noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting
- mental: to do with the mind
- intention: what the mind means to do; the mind's choosing
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- fall away: to end; to stop; to be gone
- wrong view: a wrong idea about what is real, such as the idea that there is a lasting self
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- insight: seeing into something; here, seeing clearly for oneself that there is only mind and matter
- result: what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed
- reality: something that is really there, not only a name or an idea
- awareness: noticing what is really there right now; another word for mindfulness
- meditation: developing the mind; people use this word in many different ways
- grudged: to give unwillingly
- sage: a wise person
- envy: being unhappy because someone else has something good
- counsellor: a person who gives advice to a king
- prospered: to do well; to grow rich
- courtier: a person who serves at a king's court
- endure: to bear something hard without giving up
- strenuous: needing great effort
Chapter 6. Khanti (patience)
Khanti (patience) is acceptance. The book says it has a wide meaning: patience is needed not only with what is unpleasant, but also with what is pleasant, so that lobha (attachment1wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go) does not arise2to come up; to begin; to happen when something delightful appears.
| Khanti (patience) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | acceptance |
| What it does | endures3to bear something hard without giving up the desirable and the undesirable |
| How it shows itself | tolerance4putting up with things and people one does not like, not fighting back |
| What it needs | seeing things as they really are |
Two kinds of endurance. Someone may stay awake all night in order to get what he wants. That is endurance with lobha (attachment). The question is whether a person can put up with as much as that in order to develop kusala (good). That kind of endurance is the perfection5a good quality made as full and strong as it can be of patience.
“It is very hot.” With patience a person can stand heat or cold. That does not mean the weather changes. It means that because of hot or cold weather, akusala citta (bad consciousness6a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing) does not arise. If the weather is liked, there is lobha (attachment); if it is disliked, there is dosa (aversion7not liking something and wanting it to go away; anger, even a little); either way there is no patience. A person may say “It is very hot,” and akusala citta (bad consciousness) has probably already arisen. Patience with one’s surroundings, the weather, the place, the dhamma of each moment, is called adhivāsanā khanti (patience with one’s surroundings). The ancient texts say it is the highest tapa (burning away).
With people. People who do everything quickly should be patient with people who are slow. There is patience in speech too: before speaking, considering whether what is about to be said is of any use, and if it is not, keeping quiet. And there is no person who is patient. There are only sobhana cetasika (beautiful mental factors8something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering) that have been developed.
What the commentary says of patience. The commentary9an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear praises patience in a long passage. Patience is “the unimpeded10not held back by anything weapon of the good”, because it drives out anger, the enemy of all good qualities. It is “a stream of water extinguishing the fire of anger”, “an ocean on account of its depth”, and “a staircase ascending to the worlds of the gods and Brahmas”. Then it gives thoughts for the moment when someone does wrong to us:
- If there were no wrong-doers11a person who does wrong, how could the perfection of patience ever be accomplished? A wrong-doer is also a benefactor12a person who gives help or money.
- All beings13any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being are like my own children. Who becomes angry over the misdeeds14a wrong act of his own children?
- The deed15something done; an act, good or bad by which wrong was done, and the one who did it, have at this very moment ceased16stopping; coming to an end. With whom, then, should there be anger now?
- If the wrong-doer has good qualities, there is no reason to be angry with him. If he has none, he deserves compassion17wanting to help someone who is suffering.
- Anger is the only real enemy, and when one has patience one has no enemies.
The buffalo and the monkey. The Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was once born as a buffalo. A monkey came and dirtied him four times, on his shoulder, his forehead and his eyebrows. A yakkha (a spirit) told him to kill the monkey. The buffalo did not give in to anger. He wanted to keep his sīla (good conduct) pure, and he wanted to become a Buddha. He said that someone of wisdom, who forgives disrespect from the low, the middling18in the middle; neither good nor bad and the high, obtains what he aspired19to want very much to reach something high to. Patience is to be developed towards everybody.
Dhamma and Adhamma. In another life the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was a devaputta (son of a heavenly being) named Dhamma, and Devadatta was Adhamma. Dhamma came among people and taught the ten good deeds, and Adhamma taught the ten evil ones. One day their chariots20a cart with two wheels pulled by horses, used in old times for war and travel met in mid-air, and each claimed the right of way. Adhamma said:
By iron gold is beaten, nor do we
Gold used for beating iron ever see:
If Wrong against Right shall win the fight today,
Iron as beautiful as gold will be.
Dhamma answered that he would swallow all those evil words and give him the way. He gave way, with patience and loving-kindness21wishing others well; friendliness to everyone. And the earth opened and swallowed Adhamma. There is a lesson here for everyone who joins in blaming a wrongdoer again and again: at that moment the citta (consciousness) is akusala (bad), and the person is really on the side of Adhamma, not of Dhamma.
King Pukkusāti. King Pukkusāti ruled in Takkasilā and King Bimbisāra ruled in Rājagaha (two cities of ancient India). They had never met, but they became friends through the merchants who travelled between them. Pukkusāti sent Bimbisāra eight precious cloths. Bimbisāra wondered what he could send back that was finer. He was a sotāpanna (stream-enterer), and nothing gave him joy but the Tiratana (the Triple Gem: the Buddha, his teaching and his enlightened22the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away disciples23a pupil; someone who follows a teacher). So he had a sheet of gold made, and on it he had written the qualities of the Buddha, the ten perfections, the qualities of the Dhamma (the teaching) and the Saṅgha (the enlightened disciples), and the way to practise mindfulness24noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting of breathing. At the end he wrote that if his friend could really grasp this, he should become a monk25a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life. He put the sheet in a box, that box in a golden box, and so on, box within box, and sent it off on his best elephant.
Pukkusāti opened the boxes alone in his palace and began to read. When he read of the qualities of the Buddha, such joy arose that the hairs of his body stood on end, and he had to wait before he could read on. Then he practised mindfulness of breathing and reached jhāna (deep calm of mind). For a month nobody saw him but his page. The citizens complained that the king no longer looked after the city. The king asked himself: “Shall we maintain the Kingdom or shall we maintain the teachings?” He answered: the teachings. He cut off his hair with his sword, put on two yellow robes, took an earthenware26made of baked clay bowl, and walked out of the palace. Nobody recognised him.
He walked on foot, as the Buddha had done. His feet, which had never walked on hot ground, blistered and bled. He ate the coarse27rough; not fine food of the merchants he travelled with as if it were divine food. Because the letter said the Buddha had appeared at Rājagaha, he walked past Sāvatthī, where the Buddha really was, and on to Rājagaha. There a villager told him that the Buddha was at Sāvatthī. It was evening, so he took lodging in the workshop of a potter.
That morning the Buddha had seen him with his mind, and had thought: if I do not go, he will die tomorrow without reaching the third stage of enlightenment. So the Buddha walked forty-five leagues in half a day, came to the potter’s door and asked, as an ordinary monk, whether he might spend one night there. “Spacious, friend, is the potter’s dwelling,” said Pukkusāti; “stay, friend, according to your pleasure.” The Buddha spread grass on the dirty floor among the broken pots and sat down as if in his own fragrant chamber.
Later the Buddha asked him whose teaching he followed. “The recluse28a person who lives apart from the world to seek the truth Gotama,” said Pukkusāti, and told him that he had never seen the Buddha and would not know him if he saw him. Then the Buddha taught him that the elements29one of the basic parts that everything is made of of earth, water, fire, wind, space and consciousness are not mine, not I, not myself. As he listened, Pukkusāti understood who was speaking. He bowed his head to the Buddha’s feet and asked forgiveness for having called the Teacher “friend”. The Buddha forgave him. Pukkusāti went out to look for a bowl and robe so that he could be ordained30made a monk, and a cow swerved and killed him. The Buddha said that he had become an anāgāmī (non-returner) and would reach nibbāna (the end of all troubles) without returning to this world. Pukkusāti, who gave up a kingdom and walked all that way, must have had the utmost patience. And the Buddha, who walked the same road and slept on the floor of a potter’s shed, shows the patience to be developed with regard to seats and beds and everything in one’s surroundings.
The teaching of the Buddhas. The Ovāda-pāṭimokkha (the exhortation31an urging; earnest advice that sums up the teaching) begins with patience:
Khantī paramaṃ tapo titikkhā: patience, endurance, is the highest austerity32a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living.
Nibbānaṃ paramaṃ vadanti Buddhā: nibbāna is supreme, the Buddhas say.
Na hi pabbajito parūpaghātī: he is not a recluse who harms another.Sabbapāpassa akaraṇaṃ: not doing any evil,
kusalassa upasampadā: doing what is good,
sacittapariyodapanaṃ: purifying33to make clean; cleanness one’s own mind,
etaṃ Buddhāna sāsanaṃ: this is the teaching of the Buddhas.
A person who harms another, even a fly or a mosquito, cannot be called a recluse, because he lacks adhivāsanā khanti (patience with his surroundings).
The harm of impatience. The Buddha listed five things: the impatient person is not dear to many people; he is full of ill will34wishing someone harm; much harm comes to him; he dies confused; and he is reborn35being born again in a new life after this one ends in an unhappy place. An angry mind at the moment of death is a danger far worse than any danger in this world. Patience is needed above all to listen to the Dhamma, because the perfections take a very long time to develop.
The old monk and his sons. The Kassapamandiya Jātaka (birth story number 312) was told about an old monk. A young man had become a monk and soon an arahant (fully enlightened). When his mother died he persuaded his father and his younger brother to become monks too. One day the three were walking back to the Jeta Grove. The elder brother went ahead and told the novice36a boy or young man who has begun training to be a monk, the younger brother, to bring their father along slowly. The old man walked very slowly, and the boy, to hurry him, butted him in the back with his head. The old man was so angry that he turned round and walked back to where they had started, and this went on until it was dark. The next day the Buddha blamed the old monk, not the boy, and said that he had behaved the same way in a past life. In that life the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was an ascetic, and the old monk was his father. The son said to him: “Father, young boys are just like earthen vessels, they are broken in a moment. Once they are broken it is not possible to mend them. Young boys may be abusive37to treat or speak to someone cruelly and rudely or censure38blame; telling someone off others, but old men should bear with them patiently.” And he spoke these lines:
Even wise men may quarrel,
But quickly they can become closely united again.
But fools part asunder like untempered39not softened clay,
They cannot calm down their hate.
The old recluse trained himself from then on. But in his next life, the book says, he acted as he used to act. Defilements40something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest that have not been removed lie quiet and can arise at any time. The only cure is to develop paññā (wisdom) with patience, little by little.
Hard words in this chapter
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- endure: to bear something hard without giving up
- tolerant: putting up with things and people one does not like
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- aversion: not liking something and wanting it to go away; anger, even a little
- mental factor: something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- unimpeded: not held back by anything
- wrong-doer: a person who does wrong
- benefactor: a person who gives help or money
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- misdeed: a wrong act
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- cessation: stopping; coming to an end
- compassion: wanting to help someone who is suffering
- middling: in the middle; neither good nor bad
- aspire: to want very much to reach something high
- chariot: a cart with two wheels pulled by horses, used in old times for war and travel
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- disciple: a pupil; someone who follows a teacher
- mindfulness: noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- earthenware: made of baked clay
- coarse: rough; not fine
- recluse: a person who lives apart from the world to seek the truth
- element: one of the basic parts that everything is made of
- ordained: made a monk
- exhortation: an urging; earnest advice
- ascetic: a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living
- purify: to make clean; cleanness
- ill will: wishing someone harm
- rebirth: being born again in a new life after this one ends
- novice: a boy or young man who has begun training to be a monk
- abuse: to treat or speak to someone cruelly and rudely
- censure: blame; telling someone off
- untempered: not softened
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
Quiz 3 (chapters 5 and 6)
Click an answer. Each question tells you at once whether it is right. For the written ones, show the answer and mark yourself.
Chapter 7. Sacca (truthfulness)
Sacca (truthfulness1always telling the truth and keeping to it) is being truthful through body, speech and mind. To reach the four noble truths, a person has to be truthful about himself: truthful about what is really there in the mind. Kusala (good) is kusala (good) and akusala (bad) is akusala (bad), whether it arises2to come up; to begin; to happen in oneself or in someone else.
| Sacca (truthfulness) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | not deceiving3to fool someone; to make them believe what is not true in speech |
| What it does | finds out what is really so |
| How it shows itself | excellence |
| What it needs | honesty |
Bean soup. The Tipiṭaka (the Three Baskets) compares deceitful speech to bean soup. When bean soup is cooked, some beans are cooked and some are not, and whoever eats it now and then bites on a hard one. Speech is like that. When a person talks a great deal, some false words may be mixed in. Or everything he says may be true, from the first word to the last. Only paññā (wisdom) knows which it is.
Truthful to the Triple Gem. Truthfulness begins with truthfulness towards the Tiratana (the Triple Gem: the Buddha, the Dhamma, his teaching, and the Saṅgha, his enlightened4the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away disciples5a pupil; someone who follows a teacher). When a person sees a Buddha statue, is there respect for the Buddha’s qualities, or is there a request for favours: protection, possessions, praise? That question shows how truthful the citta (consciousness6a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing) is. Being truthful to the Dhamma (the teaching) means studying it in order to understand it, not in order to gain anything.
“Thus have I heard.” After the Buddha’s passing, five hundred arahant (fully enlightened) monks7a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life met to recite8to say a text aloud from memory the whole teaching together. This meeting is called the First Council9a big meeting of the elder monks to settle something. The Venerable Ānanda, who had been the Buddha’s attendant and had heard all his discourses10a talk or sermon; here, one of the Buddha’s talks written down, sat down in the teacher’s seat to recite them. Some devas (heavenly beings11any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being) thought that Ānanda must now have become a Buddha himself. Ānanda knew their thoughts, and he would not accept praise for a quality he did not have. So he began with the words evaṃ me sutaṃ (thus have I heard): “On one occasion the Blessed One was living at Sāvatthī in Jeta’s Wood, Anāthapiṇḍika’s Park”. By those words he showed that he was only a disciple, repeating what he had heard. The five hundred arahants (fully enlightened ones) and thousands of devas (heavenly beings) cried “sādhu” (good), the earth trembled and flowers fell from the sky.
Those words still open every discourse in the Tipiṭaka (the Three Baskets). The Buddha is gone, but the Dhamma (the teaching) itself is now the teacher.
Not by water. On cold winter nights, a crowd of ascetics12a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living were plunging into the river and climbing out again, believing that this made them pure. The Buddha saw them and said:
Not by water is one pure, tho’ many folk bathe here.
In whom is truth and dhamma, he is pure and he’s a brāhmin.
Light is the enemy of darkness, and knowledge is the enemy of ignorance13not knowing; not understanding what is really there. Water does not destroy the roots of evil, so water cannot wash evil away. If it could, the fish and the tortoises, the cows and the buffaloes would all be pure. What makes a person pure is truth.
How the Bodhisatta practised. The commentary14an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear gives a short rule for the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be): “He should work energetically for the welfare of beings, be capable of enduring15to bear something hard without giving up everything whether desirable or undesirable, and should speak without deception.” It adds: “He should suffuse all beings with universal16found in every one; here, mental factors that come with every moment of mind loving-kindness17wishing others well; friendliness to everyone and compassion18wanting to help someone who is suffering.” People usually have mettā (loving-kindness) for good people and not for bad ones. But when someone looks down on a person who does wrong, the citta (consciousness) of the one who looks down is akusala (bad), the same kind as the wrongdoer19a person who does wrong’s. The commentary also says: “Without truthfulness, virtue, etc., is impossible, and there can be no practice in accordance with one’s vows.” The Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) made a vow to become a Buddha. A vow can only be kept by someone who is firm in truth.
Hārita, who would not lie. In one life the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was born into a very rich family, and because of his golden skin they called him Hārita. When his parents died he thought: I too will die. So he gave away his wealth and became a recluse20a person who lives apart from the world to seek the truth in the Himālaya, where he reached deep calm of mind and the higher powers.
One day he came to Vārāṇasī (a city in India). The king had faith in him, built him a dwelling in the royal park and fed him from the palace. He lived there twelve years. Then the king went away to settle trouble on the border and asked the queen to look after the recluse. One day, when Hārita came to the palace, he saw the queen, and the kilesa (defilements21something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest) that had lain quiet in him for thousands of aeons22a huge stretch of time, far longer than anyone can count rose up like a poisonous snake out of a box. His calm of mind vanished, he could not find sati (mindfulness23noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting), and he did wrong.
The whole city talked about it. The king would not believe it. When he came home he went to the park, bowed to the recluse, and asked whether the rumour24a story passed from person to person that may not be true was true, adding that he took it to be false. Hārita thought: if I say I did not do it, the king will believe me. But in this world there is no surer foundation than truthful speech, and someone who forsakes the truth cannot become a Buddha. In some lives a Bodhisatta (a Buddha-to-be) may break other rules, but he never tells a lie. So Hārita answered:
The rumours, great King, you have heard are true.
Infatuated25foolishly carried away by liking something by the objects26the thing that a moment of mind knows: a colour, a sound, a thought of delusion27being fooled; not seeing things as they are, I have done wrong.
The king praised his honesty and urged him to throw off the lust28strong wanting, especially for pleasure that was destroying him. Hearing this, the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) came back to himself and said:
Sense pleasures are blinding,
they cause much suffering29pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness.
They injure gravely30seriously.
I shall look for the root of sensuousness31to do with the pleasures of the senses: nice sights, sounds, tastes and so on,
I shall cut down lust with its bonds.
He regained jhāna (deep calm of mind), went back to the forest, and at the end of his life was reborn32being born again in a new life after this one ends in the brahma (highest heavenly) world. The Buddha told this story to a monk who wanted to leave the Order after seeing a beautifully dressed woman. He said that even he, as the recluse Hārita, with all his powers, had fallen because of that kind of defilement. “Why should a strong wind that strikes Mount Sineru not carry off a withered leaf?” Nobody is as steady as Mount Sineru (the great mountain at the centre of the world); people are withered leaves, and the wind is lobha (attachment33wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go), dosa (anger) and moha (ignorance). When the Buddha had explained the truths, that monk became an arahant (fully enlightened).
Kaṇhadīpāyana and the snake. In another life the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was the seer34a wise person who sees the truth Dīpāyana. For more than fifty years he was unhappy as a recluse, and he told no one. He stayed only because he feared that people would say he had left his wealth and now wanted it back. He kept his hiri (shame) and ottappa (fear of blame), and he stayed, sometimes with tears running down his face. He was called Kaṇhadīpāyana (Black Dīpāyana) because he had sat all night beside a wounded friend, and the drops of blood dried black on his body.
One day a friend came to visit with his wife and little son, Yaññadatta. The boy threw a ball, it rolled near a poisonous snake, and when the boy felt for it the snake bit him. He fell to the ground. His parents were in agony35very great pain, and the seer with them. Then Dīpāyana made a saccakiriyā (an assertion of truth). He said that for only seven days had he lived the holy life gladly, and that for more than fifty years he had lived it unwillingly, and by that truth might the poison be destroyed and Yaññadatta live. The boy stood up and was well. The Cariyāpiṭaka (Basket of Conduct) ends: “There was no one equal to me in truth- this was my perfection36a good quality made as full and strong as it can be of Truth.” Why was the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be), who had loved the homeless life for thousands of lives, unhappy in it in this one? Because nobody who is not yet enlightened is steady.
Small matters. Truthfulness is also keeping one’s word about little things, such as appointments. Even small children notice whether a person does what he says. If a person gets into the habit of small lies, lying becomes easy and he stops seeing that it is wrong. If he keeps to the truth, truthfulness becomes natural to him, and he can see the danger of akusala (bad states) at the very moment a lie is about to be told. The perfection of truthfulness has to be developed together with paññā (wisdom), and with the next perfection, adhiṭṭhāna (determination37making up one’s mind firmly and keeping to it).
Hard words in this chapter
- truthfulness: always telling the truth and keeping to it
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- deceive: to fool someone; to make them believe what is not true
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- disciple: a pupil; someone who follows a teacher
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- recite: to say a text aloud from memory
- council: a big meeting of the elder monks to settle something
- discourse: a talk or sermon; here, one of the Buddha's talks written down
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- ascetic: a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living
- ignorance: not knowing; not understanding what is really there
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- endure: to bear something hard without giving up
- universal: found in every one; here, mental factors that come with every moment of mind
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
- compassion: wanting to help someone who is suffering
- wrong-doer: a person who does wrong
- recluse: a person who lives apart from the world to seek the truth
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
- aeon: a huge stretch of time, far longer than anyone can count
- mindfulness: noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting
- rumour: a story passed from person to person that may not be true
- infatuated: foolishly carried away by liking something
- object: the thing that a moment of mind knows: a colour, a sound, a thought
- delusion: being fooled; not seeing things as they are
- lust: strong wanting, especially for pleasure
- suffering: pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness
- gravely: seriously
- sensual: to do with the pleasures of the senses: nice sights, sounds, tastes and so on
- rebirth: being born again in a new life after this one ends
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- seer: a wise person who sees the truth
- agony: very great pain
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- determination: making up one's mind firmly and keeping to it
Chapter 8. Adhiṭṭhāna (determination)
Adhiṭṭhāna (determination1making up one’s mind firmly and keeping to it) is the firm resolve to reach the four noble truths, even though the way is long and will take an endlessly long time. The ancient texts say it means the firm determination to develop the ten perfections2a good quality made as full and strong as it can be.
| Adhiṭṭhāna (determination) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | resolving upon the ten perfections |
| What it does | overcomes their opposites |
| How it shows itself | being unshakeable3cannot be shaken or moved in that task |
| What it needs | the ten perfections themselves |
Why it is needed. Kusala citta (good consciousness4a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing) arises5to come up; to begin; to happen, and shortly afterwards akusala citta (bad consciousness) arises. Sometimes there is determination for good, but when a bad moment comes and pushes towards something bad, the good is easily given up. That is why firm determination is needed. A person who is in love with pleasant sights, sounds, smells, tastes and touches will want them again and again, and will not be inclined6a leaning towards something; what one tends to do to develop the perfections at all.
Wise Temiya. This is the life in which the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) developed determination to the highest degree. It is told in the Mūgapakkha Jātaka (birth story number 538). He was the son of the king of Kāsi, and people called him Temiya, which means wet, because a great shower of rain fell on the day he was born.
King Kāsirājā ruled in Vārāṇasī (a city in India). He had sixteen thousand wives, but none of them had a child. His chief queen, Candādevī, lived a good life. On the full-moon day she kept the Uposatha (observance7keeping a rule or custom day) rules and made an act of truth: “If I have never transgressed8to break a rule; to do wrong sīla, may by this assertion of truth a son be borne to me.” Then the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was conceived.
When the prince was one month old, the king sat with the baby on his hip. Just then four robbers were brought in to be sentenced, and the king gave each of them a terrible punishment. When the baby heard his father pass those sentences, he was shaken. He was afraid of doing such deeds9something done; an act, good or bad himself and being reborn10being born again in a new life after this one ends in hell.
The next day he lay under the white umbrella of royalty and remembered his past lives: a heaven, before that hell, and before that a life as king in this very city. He thought: “I do not need the kingdom. How can I escape from this house of robbers?” A goddess who lived in the umbrella, and who had been his mother in a former life, told him the way: pretend to be dumb, crippled and deaf. From that day he did.
His parents could see none of the signs of a child who is dumb, deaf or crippled. So they began to test him. For a whole day they gave him no milk, but hungry as he was, he made no sound. For years they tried him with cakes, sweets, fruit and toys. Then they tried fear: fire, a wild elephant, snakes, a man waving a sword. He showed no fear, because he thought the danger of hell was a thousand times more fearful. They made deafening noise with conches11a big sea shell that is blown like a trumpet and drums. They smeared him with molasses12thick dark syrup made from sugar and laid him where flies swarmed. They put pans of burning coals under his bed. For sixteen years they tested him, and he did not change his mind. At sixteen they dressed him like a son of the gods and sent the most graceful women to tempt him. He held his breath so that they could not touch him, and they ran away saying he must be a yakkha (a spirit), not a man.
At last the king called the fortune-tellers13a person who claims to tell the future, who said that the boy was a person of ill luck, a danger to the king. The king ordered that the boy be taken out by the back gate and buried in the charnel14a place where the dead are buried or left ground. When Temiya heard this he rejoiced15to be glad: the wish he had held for so long was about to come true.
Queen Candādevī asked the king to give the kingdom to her son. The king refused. She asked for seven years, then six, five, four, three, two, one; then seven months, down to one; then seven days. To seven days the king agreed. So the prince was crowned and led around the city on an elephant. For five nights his mother begged him: “O Temiya, I did not sleep for sixteen years, I have wept because of you, my child, so that my eyes have become swollen and my heart is pierced with sorrow. I know that you are not cripple, deaf and dumb, do not make me utterly destitute16having nothing at all; very poor.” He did not answer.
On the sixth day the king ordered the charioteer17the driver of a chariot Sunanda to take the boy at dawn and bury him. In the morning the charioteer carried the prince down, and the queen collapsed with a cry. Temiya thought: if I do not speak, she will die of sorrow. And then: if I speak, my sixteen years will be wasted; if I keep silent, it will be for the good of myself and of my parents. He kept silent.
The chariot18a cart with two wheels pulled by horses, used in old times for war and travel went to the edge of a forest. The charioteer took a spade and began to dig. Temiya thought: “This is my time for effort.” He rubbed his hands and feet, stepped down from the chariot, and found he had strength enough to walk a hundred leagues. He lifted the chariot by its back as if it were a toy. Then he taught the charioteer: “You are dependent on me, the son of the king. If you bury me in the forest, you will commit evil. It is as if a person who sits or lies in the shade of a tree will not break the branches.” The king was the tree, the prince was the branch, and the charioteer was the traveller resting in its shade. Sunanda begged him to come home. Temiya told him about his past lives and his fear of hell, and said he would become a recluse19a person who lives apart from the world to seek the truth (a person who leaves home to train the mind). Sunanda wanted to become a recluse too. Temiya said: “O, charioteer, take the chariot back and return after you have paid your debts, because a recluse should not have debts, as is the exhortation20an urging; earnest advice of all hermits21a person who lives alone, away from other people.”
Sunanda told the king everything, and the king set out with his whole army to see his son. Temiya was living happily in a hut in the forest. The king begged him to come and rule. He refused, and taught the king the Dhamma (the Buddha’s teaching) until the king felt saṃvega (urgency22the feeling that something must be done now, without delay) and wanted to become a recluse too, together with the queen and many of the court. The Buddha said that the goddess in the umbrella was Uppalavaṇṇā, the charioteer was Sāriputta, and wise Temiya was himself.
Wanting is not resolving. The book tells of a person who studied the Dhamma (the teaching), thought about the long cycle of birth and death, and longed for rebirth to end. But he took no interest in developing satipaṭṭhāna (mindfulness23noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting of realities24something that is really there, not only a name or an idea). Wanting the end of rebirth is not the same as being firm in one’s determination to develop paññā (wisdom).
Four firm foundations. The commentary25an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear names four adhiṭṭhāna dhamma (foundations), basic to all the perfections:
- Sacca (truthfulness26always telling the truth and keeping to it). Firmness in truth, even in small matters, such as keeping an appointment. A person firm in truth stays truthful even when his life is in danger.
- Cāga (giving up). Not only giving things away, but giving up kilesa (defilements27something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest). This includes guarding the six doors: the eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body and mind. The Venerable Sāriputta, when a monk28a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life falsely accused him, felt no ill will29wishing someone harm. He said he was like a duster, which wipes up everything, clean and foul, without disgust.
- Upasama (calm). Not being disturbed by sights, sounds, smells, tastes and touches.
- Paññā (wisdom). Gained by listening to the teaching, considering it, and asking questions. Someone who thinks that listening once or twice will free him from the cycle of birth and death does not yet have firm determination.
The great resolve. A person who aspires30to want very much to reach something high to become a Sammāsambuddha (a fully enlightened31the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away Buddha) needs extreme dedication and strong desire. The Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) showed it in his life as Sumedha: when people were clearing a road for the Buddha Dīpaṅkara and it was not ready, Sumedha threw himself down in the mud so that the Buddha could walk on him. If such a person heard that only one who could cross a whole world full of water by the strength of his arms could become a Buddha, he would not shrink away. Because of the Buddha’s great compassion32wanting to help someone who is suffering, nobody now has to do such things. The teaching is here to be listened to.
Hard words in this chapter
- determination: making up one's mind firmly and keeping to it
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- unshakeable: cannot be shaken or moved
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- inclination: a leaning towards something; what one tends to do
- observance: keeping a rule or custom
- transgressed: to break a rule; to do wrong
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- rebirth: being born again in a new life after this one ends
- conch: a big sea shell that is blown like a trumpet
- molasses: thick dark syrup made from sugar
- fortune-teller: a person who claims to tell the future
- cemetery: a place where the dead are buried or left
- rejoice: to be glad
- destitute: having nothing at all; very poor
- charioteer: the driver of a chariot
- chariot: a cart with two wheels pulled by horses, used in old times for war and travel
- recluse: a person who lives apart from the world to seek the truth
- exhortation: an urging; earnest advice
- hermit: a person who lives alone, away from other people
- urgency: the feeling that something must be done now, without delay
- mindfulness: noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting
- reality: something that is really there, not only a name or an idea
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- truthfulness: always telling the truth and keeping to it
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- ill will: wishing someone harm
- aspire: to want very much to reach something high
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- compassion: wanting to help someone who is suffering
Quiz 4 (chapters 7 and 8)
Click an answer. Each question tells you at once whether it is right. For the written ones, show the answer and mark yourself.
Chapter 9. Mettā (loving-kindness)
Mettā (loving-kindness1wishing others well; friendliness to everyone) is wishing for the welfare of living beings2any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being. In the Abhidhamma it is the cetasika (mental factor3something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering) adosa (non-hate), the reality4something that is really there, not only a name or an idea that is freedom from anger. When mettā (loving-kindness) arises5to come up; to begin; to happen, there is at that moment no hate and no aversion6not liking something and wanting it to go away; anger, even a little at all.
| Mettā (loving-kindness) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | promoting the welfare of living beings |
| What it does | provides for their welfare, or removes resentment7a sore, angry feeling about being treated badly |
| How it shows itself | kindliness8kindness |
| What it needs | seeing the agreeable side of beings |
Why it comes after determination. Loving-kindness follows determination9making up one’s mind firmly and keeping to it in the list of ten because it is loving-kindness that carries out the determination to work for the welfare of others. That work goes on steadily only when determination is unshakeable10cannot be shaken or moved.
The one that is forgotten. A person may feel that he has already given enough, kept the rules well enough, is patient and speaks the truth. But has he developed mettā (loving-kindness) as much as the others? It is easy to forget to help, again and again, and to help strangers as readily as friends. If the wish to help others is weak, the reason should be looked for. Is it conceit11thinking oneself better than others, or worse, or just as good; pride that compares? Is it the thought that helping is a waste of time? Is it worrying about what the other person will think? The book says that what another person thinks of us concerns only him, not us.
No limits. True mettā (loving-kindness) has no limits. If it is kept for some people and not others, it may not be mettā (loving-kindness) at all, but lobha (attachment12wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go), which only looks like kindness from the outside. The test is this: if there is true mettā (loving-kindness), a kind deed13something done; an act, good or bad for a stranger feels exactly the same as a kind deed for someone close.
A mother and her child. The Tipiṭaka (the Three Baskets) compares deeds done with mettā (loving-kindness) to a mother’s care for her child. She gives up everything for the child, and looks after it even when it is dirty. But there is a warning. A mother’s attachment to her own child is not mettā (loving-kindness). The picture is of her selfless care. A person who can care for other people the way a good mother cares for her baby practises mettā (loving-kindness).
The woman in Indonesia. A monk14a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life told of a woman in Indonesia whose husband was killed by a young man’s reckless15doing things without care for what may happen driving. She did not take him to court, because she did not want to cause unhappiness to anyone. More than that, she said she would pay for the young man’s education. The book says this was very hard for her, and she did it. Such acts can be done by someone who has built up loving-kindness and compassion16wanting to help someone who is suffering over a long time.
Anger lasts one moment. When anger arises towards someone, it helps to know that anger arises only for a moment and then falls away17to end; to stop; to be gone, and that mettā (loving-kindness) can arise in its place. A person who stays angry for a long time can see from that how much is still to be done.
The four divine abidings. Mettā (loving-kindness) is one of four brahmavihāra (divine abidings):
- Mettā (loving-kindness): wishing beings well.
- Karuṇā (compassion): wishing to take away a being’s suffering18pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness.
- Muditā (sympathetic joy19being glad when someone else is happy or does well): being glad at another’s happiness and success.
- Upekkhā (equanimity20an even, calm mind that is not shaken by good luck or bad): being even-minded21having a mind that stays level and calm whatever happens towards all beings, with neither attachment nor aversion.
The Atthasālinī (The Expositor) gives a picture of four children. Mettā (loving-kindness) is like the care for a small child, whom everyone wishes to grow up well. Karuṇā (compassion) is like the care for a sick child, whom the mother wants to see cured. Muditā (sympathetic joy) is like the gladness of parents whose child is growing up well. Upekkhā (equanimity) is like the calm of parents whose child can now manage his own affairs.
Look-alikes. Each of the four has a near enemy, a state that looks like it but is akusala (bad). When a person is thrilled by someone else’s gain and praise, there may be lobha (attachment), not muditā (sympathetic joy). The near enemy of upekkhā (equanimity) is plain indifference22neither pleasant nor unpleasant; in the middle. When something is seen and there is no reaction, that is not always kusala (good). It may be moha (ignorance23not knowing; not understanding what is really there). Only paññā (wisdom) can tell them apart.
Kindness at the right time. When people see someone doing a harmful deed, they are upset and hope he will get what he deserves. When later he suffers the result24what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed, they feel sorry for him. That is the wrong way round. The moment for mettā (loving-kindness) and karuṇā (compassion) is the moment he does the deed, because that deed is the cause of his future suffering. “If one sympathizes25to feel for someone; to share their feelings with him when he receives an undesirable result, one sympathizes too late.” A real friend helps a person to give up bad deeds.
No persons. In the ultimate26the deepest and most real; what is really there when all the names are taken away sense there are no beings and no persons; there are only realities arising and falling away. A person who lives by the Dhamma (the teaching) comes to know at once when there is no loving-kindness but akusala (bad states), and can then have loving-kindness at once, even for a person who behaves like an enemy.
Hard words in this chapter
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- mental factor: something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering
- reality: something that is really there, not only a name or an idea
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- aversion: not liking something and wanting it to go away; anger, even a little
- resentment: a sore, angry feeling about being treated badly
- kindliness: kindness
- determination: making up one's mind firmly and keeping to it
- unshakeable: cannot be shaken or moved
- conceit: thinking oneself better than others, or worse, or just as good; pride that compares
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- recklessness: doing things without care for what may happen
- compassion: wanting to help someone who is suffering
- fall away: to end; to stop; to be gone
- suffering: pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness
- sympathetic joy: being glad when someone else is happy or does well
- equanimity: an even, calm mind that is not shaken by good luck or bad
- even-mindedness: having a mind that stays level and calm whatever happens
- indifferent: neither pleasant nor unpleasant; in the middle
- ignorance: not knowing; not understanding what is really there
- result: what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed
- sympathize: to feel for someone; to share their feelings
- ultimate: the deepest and most real; what is really there when all the names are taken away
Chapter 10. Upekkhā (even-mindedness)
Upekkhā (even-mindedness1having a mind that stays level and calm whatever happens) is not being disturbed by the troublesome conduct of people, or by the ups and downs of life, pleasant or unpleasant: gain and loss, praise and blame. The book compares it to a pair of scales that is well balanced.
| Upekkhā (even-mindedness) | |
|---|---|
| What it is | taking a neutral2neither one thing nor the other; in the middle stance towards beings3any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being |
| What it does | sees things impartially4fair to all sides; not taking sides |
| How it shows itself | the dying down of attraction and repulsion5strong dislike; being pushed away |
| What it needs | the thought that all beings inherit the results6what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed of their own kamma (deeds7something done; an act, good or bad) |
The snake and the man who kills it. When people see someone kill a snake, they believe they feel compassion8wanting to help someone who is suffering for the snake. In reality9something that is really there, not only a name or an idea, the book says, they are disturbed by aversion10not liking something and wanting it to go away; anger, even a little towards the person who kills it. There may not be loving-kindness11wishing others well; friendliness to everyone at all. But there can be upekkhā (even-mindedness) when it is remembered that everyone receives the results of his own deeds. And there can be compassion for the killer, who will receive the result of what he does. A person with upekkhā (even-mindedness) is not disturbed, and does not say unsuitable things to someone doing wrong. A disturbed citta (consciousness12a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing) is akusala (bad), even when it feels righteous.
No expectations. A person should not have expectations about when the four noble truths will be seen. As long as many kilesa (defilements13something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest) arise14to come up; to begin; to happen all the time, the goal is far away. The thing to do is to develop every kind of good, patiently, so that the conditions15something that has to be there before another thing can happen are slowly built up.
Each perfection is the enemy of attachment. The commentary16an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear explains how each of the ten perfections17a good quality made as full and strong as it can be works against lobha (attachment18wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go), dosa (anger) and moha (ignorance19not knowing; not understanding what is really there). Giving works against them because there is no attachment to the gift, no hate towards the one who receives it, and no ignorance about the result. The book gives an example. A person sees a beggar and notices that he is strong, or sees that he drags a disabled child along, and feels irritated, and so does not give. At that moment there is aversion towards the receiver, and no giving. Wisdom works against them because they make a person blind and wisdom gives back sight. Patience works against lobha (attachment) “by accepting the desirable, the undesirable, and emptiness”. And upekkhā (even-mindedness) works against them by driving out attraction to pleasant things and repulsion from unpleasant ones, and by going on evenly whatever happens.
A thousand goods on the doorstep. An ancient commentary compares the Buddha’s teaching to a thousand goods laid down on the doorstep of every house, for the family inside. Some people open the door and take them in. Others never open the door. Another passage compares people’s confusion about cause and result to a cotton thread so tangled into a knot that nobody can undo it alone. Only two kinds of person can undo it: a Sammāsambuddha (a fully enlightened20the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away Buddha who teaches the world) and a Paccekabuddha (a silent Buddha, who finds the truth alone but does not teach it).
Lomahaṃsa, who slept among the bones. The Cariyāpiṭaka (Basket of Conduct) calls this the Great Astounding Conduct. It is the life in which the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) developed upekkhā (even-mindedness) to the highest degree.
He was born into a wealthy family. When his parents died, his relatives begged him to take charge of the family’s wealth. But he had thought about impermanence21not lasting; passing away, and he felt saṃvega (urgency22the feeling that something must be done now, without delay). He thought of becoming a monk23a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life. Then he reflected that a monk receives honour and gifts, and he did not want honour or gain. So he decided to live with just enough, as a layman24an ordinary person who follows the teaching while living at home, and to be even-minded in gain and loss and the other ups and downs of the world.
He resolved: “I shall accumulate25to gather up bit by bit, so that there is more and more of it the practice of supreme patience, enduring26to bear something hard without giving up derisive27laughing at someone unkindly speech from others. I shall develop the perfection of equanimity28an even, calm mind that is not shaken by good luck or bad to the highest degree.” He left home in the clothes he was wearing. Though he was not dumb, he behaved as if he were dumb, and people mocked him because he looked like a fool. He wandered from village to village, staying one night in each place, and where he was mocked the most, he stayed longer. When his clothes wore out he went about in a rag.
In one village he met a gang of children who were cruel and violent, and threw dust over the backs of the old and poor. He thought: here is a chance to develop the perfection of even-mindedness, and he stayed. When the children began to torment29to cause great pain to him, he pretended to be afraid, so that they would follow him. He led them to the cemetery30a place where the dead are buried or left, lay down, and took a skeleton for a pillow. The children spat on him, poked grass into his ears and jeered, day after day. Wise people who saw it told the children to stop, and honoured him with flowers, scented oils and food.
The Buddha said of that life: “I slept in a cemetery, taking as a pillow the skeleton of a corpse31a dead body. I had evenmindedness with regard to what is clean and what is dirty.” The children made him suffer, the wise people gave him pleasant things; he was even-minded to all of them. He had no special affection for those who helped him, and no angry words or thoughts of revenge for those who did not. “I am evenminded towards happiness and misery, towards honour and dishonour32loss of respect; shame; I am impartial towards everything, and this is my perfection of equanimity.”
The commentary adds that in that same life he developed all ten perfections. He was not a monk, but he was a monk at heart, and his life was like the life of an arahant (a fully enlightened person).
All ten. The book ends with the list once more: dāna (giving), sīla (good conduct), nekkhamma (letting go), paññā (wisdom), viriya (energy33effort; the strength that keeps on going), khanti (patience), sacca (truthfulness34always telling the truth and keeping to it), adhiṭṭhāna (determination35making up one’s mind firmly and keeping to it), mettā (loving-kindness) and upekkhā (even-mindedness). None of them should be left out. All of them are needed, and developing them is the way to develop paññā (wisdom).
Hard words in this chapter
- even-mindedness: having a mind that stays level and calm whatever happens
- neutral: neither one thing nor the other; in the middle
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- impartial: fair to all sides; not taking sides
- repulsion: strong dislike; being pushed away
- result: what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- compassion: wanting to help someone who is suffering
- reality: something that is really there, not only a name or an idea
- aversion: not liking something and wanting it to go away; anger, even a little
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- condition: something that has to be there before another thing can happen
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- ignorance: not knowing; not understanding what is really there
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- impermanent: not lasting; passing away
- urgency: the feeling that something must be done now, without delay
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha's rule of life
- lay: an ordinary person who follows the teaching while living at home
- accumulate: to gather up bit by bit, so that there is more and more of it
- endure: to bear something hard without giving up
- derisive: laughing at someone unkindly
- equanimity: an even, calm mind that is not shaken by good luck or bad
- torment: to cause great pain to
- cemetery: a place where the dead are buried or left
- corpse: a dead body
- dishonour: loss of respect; shame
- energy: effort; the strength that keeps on going
- truthfulness: always telling the truth and keeping to it
- determination: making up one's mind firmly and keeping to it
Quiz 5 (chapters 9 and 10)
Click an answer. Each question tells you at once whether it is right. For the written ones, show the answer and mark yourself.
The defilements of the perfections
The book ends with a short chapter on what makes each perfection imperfect. The commentary calls this the kilesa (defilement) of the perfections. The rule is simple: “When attachment arises, when we have enjoyment and clinging, the ten perfections are defiled.” What makes each one imperfect is a thought that picks and chooses where there should be no picking and choosing.
| Perfection | What makes it imperfect |
|---|---|
| dāna (giving) | picking and choosing over gifts and over who receives them |
| sīla (good conduct) | picking and choosing over which people and which days the rules are kept for |
| nekkhamma (letting go) | delighting in sense pleasures and in being born again |
| paññā (wisdom) | thoughts of “I” and “mine”, even the thought “my wisdom” |
| viriya (energy) | leaning towards laziness or towards restlessness |
| khanti (patience) | thoughts of oneself and of others |
| sacca (truthfulness) | claiming to have seen what was not seen |
| adhiṭṭhāna (determination) | seeing faults in the things that lead to enlightenment, and good in their opposites |
| mettā (loving-kindness) | confusing what is harmful with what is helpful |
| upekkhā (even-mindedness) | picking and choosing between the pleasant and the unpleasant |
The book gives two examples for sīla (good conduct). Some people keep the rules of respect towards particular persons, such as their parents, but not towards other people. Some keep the rules only on the Uposatha (observance) day, the full-moon and new-moon days, and think they are perfect in conduct, although on the other days they do not keep them. And for upekkhā (even-mindedness) she notes that a person may be even-minded about the unpleasant but not about the pleasant.
The last words of the book are these. The more the Dhamma (the teaching) is understood, the more a person will want to practise it. The perfections may have seemed beyond reach. But if the benefit of each one is seen, and they are developed little by little, they will in the end be accomplished. Listening to the Dhamma and studying it is of the greatest benefit, because it makes it possible to apply the Dhamma in daily life, and to develop satipaṭṭhāna (mindfulness of realities) together with all ten perfections.
Word list
Every Pali word in this book, with the English used for it. The words are in the order of the English alphabet, ignoring the marks on the letters.
| Pali | English |
|---|---|
| abhaya dāna | giving freedom from fear |
| Abhidhamma | the higher teaching |
| adhiṭṭhāna | determination |
| adhiṭṭhāna dhamma | foundations |
| adhivāsanā khanti | patience with one’s surroundings |
| adosa | non-hate |
| akusala | bad |
| akusala citta | bad consciousness |
| akusala kamma | bad deed |
| āmisa dāna | giving things |
| anāgāmī | non-returner, the third stage of enlightenment |
| anattā | non-self |
| anumodana | rejoicing in another’s good deed |
| arahant | fully enlightened |
| ariya aṭṭhaṅgika magga | the noble eightfold path |
| Atthasālinī | The Expositor, an ancient commentary |
| avijjā | ignorance |
| Bodhisatta | the Buddha-to-be |
| brahma | highest heavenly |
| brahmavihāra | divine abidings |
| cāga | giving up |
| cāritta sīla | conduct as doing |
| Cariyāpiṭaka | Basket of Conduct |
| cetanā | intention |
| cetasika | mental factors |
| citta | consciousness |
| Cūḷaniddesa | a book of the Tipiṭaka |
| dāna | giving |
| deva | heavenly being |
| devaputta | son of a heavenly being |
| Dhamma | the teaching |
| dhamma dāna | giving the teaching |
| dosa | anger |
| dukkha | suffering |
| evaṃ me sutaṃ | thus have I heard |
| hiri | shame |
| Jātaka | birth stories |
| jhāna | deep calm of mind |
| kāma vitakka | thinking about sense pleasures |
| kamma | deeds and their results |
| karuṇā | compassion |
| kassapamandiya jātaka | birth story number 312 |
| khaṇika maraṇa | momentary death |
| khanti | patience |
| kilesa | defilements |
| kusala | good |
| kusala citta | good consciousness |
| lobha | attachment |
| mahā-dāna | a great offering of gifts |
| mettā | loving-kindness |
| moha | ignorance |
| muditā | sympathetic joy |
| Mūgapakkha Jātaka | birth story number 538 |
| nāma | mind |
| nekkhamma | letting go |
| nekkhamma vitakka | thinking of letting go |
| nibbāna | the end of all troubles |
| ottappa | fear of blame |
| ovāda-pāṭimokkha | the exhortation that sums up the teaching |
| Paccekabuddha | a silent Buddha, who finds the truth alone but does not teach it |
| pañca sīla | five precepts |
| paññā | wisdom |
| pāramī | perfections |
| rūpa | matter |
| sacca | truthfulness |
| saccakiriyā | an assertion of truth |
| sakkāya-diṭṭhi | personality belief, the wrong view that there is a self |
| samādhi | a steady mind |
| sammā-ppadhāna | right efforts |
| sammā-vāyāma | right effort |
| Sammāsambuddha | a fully enlightened Buddha |
| sammuti maraṇa | conventional death |
| samuccheda maraṇa | final death |
| Saṃvara Jātaka | birth story number 462 |
| saṃvega | urgency |
| Saṅgha | the enlightened disciples |
| sati | mindfulness |
| satipaṭṭhāna | mindfulness of realities |
| sīla | good conduct |
| sobhana cetasika | beautiful mental factors |
| sotāpanna | stream-enterer |
| tapa | burning away |
| Tipiṭaka | the Three Baskets |
| Tiratana | the Triple Gem: the Buddha, his teaching and his enlightened disciples |
| upasama | calm |
| upekkhā | even-mindedness |
| Uposatha | observance |
| vāritta sīla | conduct as avoiding |
| vihiṃsā vitakka | thinking about hurting |
| vipassanā | insight |
| vīra | a hero |
| viriya | energy |
| vyāpāda vitakka | thinking with hate |
| yakkha | a spirit |
Hard words
Every hard English word in this book has a small number after it the first time it is met in a chapter, and its meaning is given at the end of that chapter. Here are all of them together, in alphabetical order.
- abuse: to treat or speak to someone cruelly and rudely
- accumulate: to gather up bit by bit, so that there is more and more of it
- aeon: a huge stretch of time, far longer than anyone can count
- agony: very great pain
- arise: to come up; to begin; to happen
- ascetic: a person who gives up home and comfort to live simply and seek the truth; or that hard way of living
- aspire: to want very much to reach something high
- attachment: wanting something and holding on to it; liking that will not let go
- aversion: not liking something and wanting it to go away; anger, even a little
- awareness: noticing what is really there right now; another word for mindfulness
- being: any living creature: a person, an animal, a heavenly being
- benefactor: a person who gives help or money
- brahmin: a man of the priestly class in ancient India
- cemetery: a place where the dead are buried or left
- censure: blame; telling someone off
- cessation: stopping; coming to an end
- chariot: a cart with two wheels pulled by horses, used in old times for war and travel
- charioteer: the driver of a chariot
- clinging: holding on tightly; not wanting to let go
- coarse: rough; not fine
- commentary: an old explanation of a text, written to make it clear
- compassion: wanting to help someone who is suffering
- conceit: thinking oneself better than others, or worse, or just as good; pride that compares
- conch: a big sea shell that is blown like a trumpet
- condition: something that has to be there before another thing can happen
- consciousness: a moment of mind that knows something, such as seeing or hearing
- conventional: the ordinary everyday way of talking, as when a pile of parts is called a chariot
- corpse: a dead body
- council: a big meeting of the elder monks to settle something
- counsellor: a person who gives advice to a king
- courtier: a person who serves at a king’s court
- deceive: to fool someone; to make them believe what is not true
- deed: something done; an act, good or bad
- defilement: something that makes the mind dirty: wanting, anger, not knowing and the rest
- delusion: being fooled; not seeing things as they are
- derisive: laughing at someone unkindly
- destitute: having nothing at all; very poor
- determination: making up one’s mind firmly and keeping to it
- disciple: a pupil; someone who follows a teacher
- discourse: a talk or sermon; here, one of the Buddha’s talks written down
- dishonour: loss of respect; shame
- earthenware: made of baked clay
- element: one of the basic parts that everything is made of
- endure: to bear something hard without giving up
- energy: effort; the strength that keeps on going
- enlightenment: the moment when the truth is seen fully and for good, and the dirt of the mind is cut away
- envy: being unhappy because someone else has something good
- equanimity: an even, calm mind that is not shaken by good luck or bad
- even-mindedness: having a mind that stays level and calm whatever happens
- exhortation: an urging; earnest advice
- fall away: to end; to stop; to be gone
- fortune-teller: a person who claims to tell the future
- generosity: giving freely and gladly
- gravely: seriously
- grief: deep sadness, as when someone dies
- grudged: to give unwillingly
- hermit: a person who lives alone, away from other people
- ignorance: not knowing; not understanding what is really there
- ill will: wishing someone harm
- immeasurable: too big to measure
- impartial: fair to all sides; not taking sides
- impermanent: not lasting; passing away
- inclination: a leaning towards something; what one tends to do
- indifferent: neither pleasant nor unpleasant; in the middle
- infatuated: foolishly carried away by liking something
- insight: seeing into something; here, seeing clearly for oneself that there is only mind and matter
- intention: what the mind means to do; the mind’s choosing
- kindliness: kindness
- lay: an ordinary person who follows the teaching while living at home
- lotus: a water flower that grows up from the mud and opens clean above the water
- loving-kindness: wishing others well; friendliness to everyone
- lust: strong wanting, especially for pleasure
- matter: the kind of reality that does not know or feel anything, such as hardness, colour or sound
- meditation: developing the mind; people use this word in many different ways
- mental: to do with the mind
- mental factor: something that goes along with each moment of mind and does its own small job, such as feeling or remembering
- merit: goodness earned by a good deed, which brings a good result later
- middling: in the middle; neither good nor bad
- mindfulness: noticing what is really there right now, without forgetting
- misdeed: a wrong act
- molasses: thick dark syrup made from sugar
- momentary: lasting only a moment
- monk: a man who has left home to follow the Buddha’s rule of life
- neutral: neither one thing nor the other; in the middle
- non-self: not a self; not a person; not anyone’s
- novice: a boy or young man who has begun training to be a monk
- object: the thing that a moment of mind knows: a colour, a sound, a thought
- observance: keeping a rule or custom
- ordained: made a monk
- perfection: a good quality made as full and strong as it can be
- precept: a rule of good conduct
- prospered: to do well; to grow rich
- purify: to make clean; cleanness
- reality: something that is really there, not only a name or an idea
- rebirth: being born again in a new life after this one ends
- recite: to say a text aloud from memory
- recklessness: doing things without care for what may happen
- recluse: a person who lives apart from the world to seek the truth
- reign: the time during which a king rules
- rejoice: to be glad
- repulsion: strong dislike; being pushed away
- resentment: a sore, angry feeling about being treated badly
- result: what comes later from a deed done before, as fruit comes from a seed
- rumour: a story passed from person to person that may not be true
- sage: a wise person
- seer: a wise person who sees the truth
- sensual: to do with the pleasures of the senses: nice sights, sounds, tastes and so on
- stinginess: not wanting to give or share; meanness
- strenuous: needing great effort
- studiously: carefully, like a hard-working student
- suffering: pain and trouble; anything that cannot give lasting happiness
- sympathetic joy: being glad when someone else is happy or does well
- sympathize: to feel for someone; to share their feelings
- tolerant: putting up with things and people one does not like
- torment: to cause great pain to
- transgressed: to break a rule; to do wrong
- truthfulness: always telling the truth and keeping to it
- ultimate: the deepest and most real; what is really there when all the names are taken away
- unimpeded: not held back by anything
- universal: found in every one; here, mental factors that come with every moment of mind
- unshakeable: cannot be shaken or moved
- untempered: not softened
- urgency: the feeling that something must be done now, without delay
- wrong view: a wrong idea about what is real, such as the idea that there is a lasting self
- wrong-doer: a person who does wrong
Where the stories come from
This book follows The Perfections Leading to Enlightenment by Sujin Boriharnwanaket, translated from the Thai by Nina van Gorkom (Zolag, London, 2007). The whole book can be read free of charge on abhidhamma.org, as a PDF or as an interactive book with questions. The ten chapters here keep to her order, her stories and, as far as a book for young readers allows, her words.
Her book draws on these ancient texts:
- The Cariyāpiṭaka (Basket of Conduct), a book of the Khuddaka Nikāya (the Minor Collection) in the Tipiṭaka (the Three Baskets), and its commentary, the Paramatthadīpanī, written by Dhammapāla. The definitions of the ten perfections (what each one is, what it does, how it shows itself and what it needs) come from this commentary, in the translation by Bhikkhu Bodhi in The All-Embracing Net of Views (Buddhist Publication Society, Kandy).
- The Jātaka (birth stories) and their commentary. The stories retold here are, by number: Akitti (480), Sona Nanda (532), Susīma (411), Yudañjaya (460), Dasaṇṇaka (401), Saṃvara (462) and Mūgapakkha, the story of Temiya (538), with others named in their chapters.
- The Ghaṭīkāra Sutta (Middle Length Sayings 81) and its commentary, for Jotipāla.
- The Mahāniddesa and Cūḷaniddesa (ancient commentaries in the Khuddaka Nikāya), for Piṅgiya, Jatukaṇṇi, the two cities and the hero.
- The Atthasālinī (The Expositor), the commentary on the Dhammasaṅgaṇī, the first book of the Abhidhamma, for the pictures of energy and of shame and fear of blame.
- The Vibhaṅga (Book of Analysis) and its commentary, the Sammohavinodanī (Dispeller of Delusion).
- The Anumāna Sutta (Middle Length Sayings 15), the Aṅguttara Nikāya (Gradual Sayings) and the Saṃyutta Nikāya (Kindred Sayings), for the suttas quoted.
Where this book quotes a sentence in quotation marks, the words are those of Sujin’s book or of the translation it uses. Everything else is retold in plainer English for readers of about ten years old. Where the ancient texts and modern scholars differ, this book follows the ancient texts.